Can You Change Your Debt Payoff Plan? When to Stay the Course and When to Switch Strategies

Listen to this episode on Apple Podcasts or on Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts. 

When Should You Change Your Debt Payoff Plan?

Sometimes the hardest part of getting out of debt isn't knowing what to do. It's sticking with the plan when you're thoroughly sick of the plan.

That's exactly where one Get the Hell Out of Debt listener finds herself. She's already paid off one credit card and is snowballing that payment into the next. Progress? Absolutely. But there's a problem.

Her third credit card is, in her words, a very "spicy" debt. It charges fees to make payments online or by phone, and paying it requires mailing an actual cheque. Every payment is a tiny bureaucratic nightmare.

So she wants to know: Can I change my debt payoff plan, or am I just looking for an excuse to quit?

It's an excellent question because there is a huge difference between abandoning a financial goal and making a smart adjustment along the way. Erin Skye Kelly, who once found herself in debt before transforming her own finances and writing Get the Hell Out of Debt, gets right into that distinction.

What Is the Difference Between Quitting and Making a Strategic Adjustment?

Here's the thing about financial goals: your destination can stay the same even when your route changes.

Erin uses a travel analogy. If you're trying to get from Florida to London, you might walk, take an Uber, fly, and walk again. The transportation changes, but you're still going to London. Debt payoff works the same way. 

The problem isn't changing strategies. The problem is changing strategies every time things get uncomfortable.

Are you changing your plan because it's smart or because you're uncomfortable?

This is one of the most useful questions in the episode.

Erin suggests asking yourself:

1. Has my vision changed, or just my feelings?

2. Do I have enough data to know whether this strategy is working?

3. Am I making a strategic adjustment, or am I simply escaping discomfort?

Those three questions can save you from a lot of financial whiplash.

How Do You Know If Your Debt Strategy Is Actually Working?

Give it enough time to produce evidence.

If you've followed a strategy for two weeks and you're bored, frustrated, or impatient, you probably don't have a strategy problem. You have a consistency problem.

Erin's point isn't that you should stubbornly follow a bad plan forever. It's that you need enough information to distinguish between a strategy that isn't working and a strategy you simply haven't given a fair shot. That's why she encourages the listener to stick with her original plan long enough to pay off the first debt before making major changes. And when you do make a change, make sure it still moves you toward the same financial destination. 

What Is the Best Way to Pay Off Debt?

Here's where Erin pushes back against the idea that there is one universally correct debt payoff method. There isn't. Different people have different debts, incomes, personalities, cash-flow challenges, and motivations. A strategy that works beautifully for one person might be completely wrong for another.

In Get the Hell Out of Debt, Erin encourages people to understand their options and make an informed decision rather than blindly following someone else's financial formula.

Should you pay off debt based on interest rate?

That's one option. The mathematical approach prioritizes debts based on their borrowing cost. Erin also points out that it's worth understanding how interest compounds, rather than looking only at the headline percentage rate. 

But that's not the only possible approach.

What other debt payoff methods are there?

You might prioritize:

• Highest interest cost

• Largest monthly payment

• Smallest monthly payment

• The debt that annoys you the most

• Another strategy that fits your specific circumstances

The important part is understanding the tradeoffs and choosing intentionally.

What Is the “Spicy Debt” Method?

Every debt has the potential to become emotionally loaded. Maybe it's the credit card with the obnoxious bank. Maybe it's the account that reminds you of a terrible financial decision. Or maybe, like this listener, it's simply the debt that makes you want to scream every time you have to make a payment.

That's your spicy debt. And surprisingly, that emotional reaction can be useful. If a particular debt makes you so irritated that you're highly motivated to eliminate it, that motivation has financial value. The smartest plan isn't necessarily the one that looks best on paper. It's the one you're actually capable of following.

Why Is Financial Integrity So Important?

This may be the deeper lesson underneath the entire episode. Erin describes integrity as doing what you said you were going to do. That sounds almost painfully boring. And that's precisely the point. Financial progress is often built through remarkably unglamorous actions: updating your net worth, having the money conversation, taking the walk, making the sales call, sticking with the plan when nobody is applauding.

Why does keeping promises to yourself matter financially?

Because every time you do what you said you would do, you build evidence that you can trust yourself. That confidence doesn't come from knowing everything. It comes from taking action.

Erin connects this directly to the philosophy behind Get the Hell Out of Debt: financial literacy isn't about blindly following an expert. It's about gaining enough knowledge and confidence to make better decisions for yourself.

How Do You Stay Committed Without Becoming Rigid?

Commitment doesn't mean refusing to change. It means refusing to abandon the destination. That's a very different thing. Successful people adjust timelines. They refine strategies. They change vehicles. They respond to circumstances. What they don't do is decide that every bump in the road means the entire goal was a terrible idea. 

For this listener, Erin ultimately gives her permission to make the adjustment because she's not abandoning debt payoff. She's simply reconsidering the order of two debts after demonstrating that she can follow through. That's the difference between flexibility and flakiness. And honestly, your finances could probably use more of the first and less of the second. 

Key Takeaways

• Changing your debt payoff strategy isn't automatically quitting.

• Ask whether your vision changed or your feelings changed.

• Don't abandon a strategy before you've gathered enough evidence.

• Consider more than interest rates when choosing your debt payoff order.

• Your most emotionally frustrating debt can sometimes become a powerful motivator.

• Financial integrity means doing what you said you would do.

• Your destination can stay the same even when your strategy changes.

• Use your net worth as an objective measure of whether you're moving forward.

• Don't follow anyone's financial advice blindly, including Erin's. Learn enough to make informed decisions for yourself.

If you've ever wondered whether you're being disciplined or just stubborn, this episode is for you.

Erin and Keri dig into the messy middle of debt payoff, where the spreadsheets meet real life, emotions get involved, and sometimes the most irritating debt in your life really does deserve special attention. You'll also hear Erin explain why integrity might be one of the most important financial skills nobody teaches you, and why doing the boring thing today can produce a very exciting result later. 

Listen to the full episode of Get the Hell Out of Debt to hear Erin's answer to Liz's specific debt dilemma and decide whether it's time to stay the course or change your route.

 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-difference-between-quitting-and-adjusting/id1462338073?i=1000773849746

Resource Links

• Erin Skye Kelly’s Book: Get the Hell Out of Debt
• Erin Skye Kelly’s Book: Naked Money Meetings 

 Get the Hell Out of Debt:

• Join our online community when you sign up for Get The Hell Out Of Debt online course. There are 3 ways to join: https://www.erinskyekelly.com/gthod-course 

Related Podcast Episodes

• When You're Out Of Motivation

• The Importance Of Finishing

• The Most Important Success Trait